
Surrounding the cemetery is a small lagoon made famous by the mobsters who found this an ideal dumping ground of men who crossed the mob during the Prohibition days. Many bodies were found here on a regular basis adding to the legendary spirits that now haunt the waters.
Famous
Ghosts of Bachelor's Grove
__________________________________
The
White Lady (Mrs. Rogers or The Madonna of Bachelor's Grove):
The lady dressed in white is known to walk the grounds of the
cemetery during a full moon. The deceased woman rumored to be
the White Lady is buried in the cemetery beside her son and can
sometimes be seen holding a baby in her arms.
The
Phantom Farmhouse:
Not all ghosts are confined to the cemetery, and not all ghost
are people. On the path leading to the cemetery, a picturesque
white farmhouse appears and then quickly disappears. Most reports
of this phenomenon happened around the 1950s.
The
Farmer and his Horse:
In the 1870's a farmer plowing the land near the cemetery got
too close to the famous lagoon, proving to be a fatal mistake.
The horse fell into the water first, pulling the plow and farmer
in with him. Almost 100 years later, two forest rangers reported
seeing the same farmer still plowing his land by the lagoon.
The
Two-Headed Ghost:
No substantial information can be found on this strange apparition.
The sinister background of the famous lagoon is known for making
this ghost; the reason for its two heads is open to interpretation.
Lights
and Orbs:
This site has common sightings of blue colored lights and orbs
that fly about the cemetery. Some other accounts talk of reds
comet-like lights flying over the graves.
Ghost
Cars:
Drivers passing through on the turnpike outside of the gravel
path will come up to a sharp curve in the road. When coming around
the curve, they collide with what seems to be a vintage 1940's
gangster car. What they learn after the first shock has past is
that there is no damage, no pain, and no other car.